SW Community
Closed Strip Club

The Pony Anderson

Anderson, IN 1106 E 53rd St 765-387-4300
Closed Opens 19:00 today
Strip Club Topless 21+
Hours
MON Closed
TUE 19:00 - 03:00
WED 19:00 - 03:00 TODAY
THU 19:00 - 03:00
FRI 19:00 - 03:00
SAT 19:00 - 03:00
SUN Closed
On tap
Private Booths
46/100

A total trainwreck from the moment you step inside.

The Pony Anderson is a total disaster from start to finish. The property is cramped and poorly maintained, which sets the tone for the rest of your experience. Overall, it's not worth the risk, unless you're in the area and desperate.

How this is scored
35/100

A cramped, run-down space with zero luxury vibes.

The atmosphere is stale, the location is sketchy, and the parking situation is a nightmare. The only thing 'luxurious' about this place is the prices they charge for subpar amenities. Unless you enjoy feeling claustrophobic and overcharged, avoid this dump.

How property is scored
HOW PROPERTY IS SCORED

Property weighting

Property weighs 7 sub-metrics — atmosphere, location, privacy, parking, luxury, amenities, capacity — each scored 0–10. They roll up into the single 0–100 property score.

Signals come from verified reviews, venue data, and website text. The overall dot on the radar is the average shape across these sub-metrics.

PROPERTY · 35/100

The room

A cramped, run-down space with zero luxury vibes.

The atmosphere is stale, the location is sketchy, and the parking situation is a nightmare. The only thing 'luxurious' about this place is the prices they charge for subpar amenities. Unless you enjoy feeling claustrophobic and overcharged, avoid this dump.

Sub-metrics (0-10)
  • Atmosphere 4.0
  • Location 4.3
  • Privacy 4.0
  • Parking 3.0
  • Luxury 1.7
  • Amenities 2.6
  • Capacity 3.0
46/100

Expect subpar service from the door to the bar.

Don't expect a warm welcome from the door staff, and don't even get me started on the bar service. The speed is glacial, the respect is nonexistent, and the cleanliness is questionable. You're better off going elsewhere.

How service is scored
HOW SERVICE IS SCORED

Service weighting

Service weighs 7 sub-metrics — door, bar, speed, respect, safety, clean, value — each scored 0–10. They roll up into the single 0–100 service score.

Signals come from verified reviews, venue data, and website text. The overall dot on the radar is the average shape across these sub-metrics.

SERVICE · 46/100

The hospitality

Expect subpar service from the door to the bar.

Don't expect a warm welcome from the door staff, and don't even get me started on the bar service. The speed is glacial, the respect is nonexistent, and the cleanliness is questionable. You're better off going elsewhere.

Sub-metrics (0-10)
  • Door service 4.3
  • Bar service 6.0
  • Speed 3.4
  • Respect 5.1
  • Safety 3.4
  • Cleanliness 4.3
  • Value 8.0
60/100

Bland drinks and overpriced snacks that taste like cardboard.

The food quality is nonexistent, and the prices are through the roof. The drinks are bland, and the snacks taste like they've been sitting out for hours. If you're hungry, bring your own food – or just eat before you come.

How food is scored
HOW FOOD IS SCORED

Food weighting

Food weighs 7 sub-metrics — quality, price, drinks, bottles, luxury, cigar, value — each scored 0–10. They roll up into the single 0–100 food score.

Signals come from verified reviews, venue data, and website text. The overall dot on the radar is the average shape across these sub-metrics.

FOOD · 60/100

The kitchen

Bland drinks and overpriced snacks that taste like cardboard.

The food quality is nonexistent, and the prices are through the roof. The drinks are bland, and the snacks taste like they've been sitting out for hours. If you're hungry, bring your own food – or just eat before you come.

Sub-metrics (0-10)
  • Food quality 1.0
  • Food prices 1.0
  • Drink prices 9.0
  • Bottle prices 4.9
  • Luxury 1.7
  • Cigars & hookah 2.6
  • Value 8.0
45/100

The dancers are forgettable, but the security is intimidating.

The dancers are okay, but they're not worth the hassle. The security is overbearing, and the professionalism is lacking. If you're looking for a memorable experience, look elsewhere – but if you just want to blend in and forget, this might be your place.

How performers is scored
HOW PERFORMERS IS SCORED

Performers weighting

Performers weighs 6 sub-metrics — talent, style, interact, pro, vip, dance — each scored 0–10. They roll up into the single 0–100 performers score.

Signals come from verified reviews, venue data, and website text. The overall dot on the radar is the average shape across these sub-metrics.

PERFORMERS · 45/100

The floor

The dancers are forgettable, but the security is intimidating.

The dancers are okay, but they're not worth the hassle. The security is overbearing, and the professionalism is lacking. If you're looking for a memorable experience, look elsewhere – but if you just want to blend in and forget, this might be your place.

Sub-metrics (0-10)
  • Talent quality 4.0
  • Appearance & style 4.0
  • Interaction 4.3
  • Professionalism 3.4
  • VIP value 6.0
  • Dance value 5.0
HOW IT'S SCORED

Overall SW Score weighting

Each point on the radar is a dimension scored 0–100, weighted by how much it shapes a night out. Balanced shapes mean well-rounded clubs; spikes mean a venue excels at one thing but not others.

Tap any dimension's own info icon to see which sub-metrics feed into it.

SW SCORE · 46/100

How scoring works

A total trainwreck from the moment you step inside.

The Pony Anderson is a total disaster from start to finish. The property is cramped and poorly maintained, which sets the tone for the rest of your experience. Overall, it's not worth the risk, unless you're in the area and desperate.

SW Score is a weighted composite across four dimensions — property, service, food, and performers — measured across 27 sub-metrics and a separate value score.

Sub-metric signals are pulled from verified reviews, venue data, and website text. Each dimension rolls up into a 0-100 score, which feeds the weighted overall.

How to read the shape: a balanced radar means a well-rounded club. A spiked shape means it excels at one thing and not others. Tap any dimension below for its full breakdown.

Dimension scores
  • Property 35
  • Service 46
  • Food 60
  • Performers 45
  • Value 65
Rate this club

Your take, one tap at a time.

A quick 6-step walkthrough — 4 categories of spiderweb ratings plus a written review at the end. Takes about 2 minutes.

0 of 27 rated

What the floor said

30 reviews
80/100 SW score
Best Cheap Drinks in Town, Decent Spot Been coming here for years. The $1 domestic beers are unbeatable, and the girls are friendly enough. It's small and kinda cramped, but that's part of the charm—feels like a neighborhood spot. Just watch your step in the parking lot at night.
60/100 SW score
Fun Night Out, But Nothing Special Went with buddies on a Saturday. The value is solid and the VIP rooms are reasonable, but the place is pretty basic—dim lighting, limited stage setup. Dancer quality was hit or miss. We had a good time anyway, mostly because we weren't dropping a ton of cash.
50/100 SW score
Underwhelming and a Bit Sketchy Not what I expected. The atmosphere is pretty dingy, and the parking area felt unsafe walking back to my car. Drinks were cheap, I'll give them that, but the whole vibe felt run-down. The VIP room was cramped too. Probably won't be back.
Read all 30 reviews — members only
Create a free account to read every real review on every club, plus VIP offers near you.
Offers Directions